Logo

Log In Sign Up |  An official publication of: American College of Emergency Physicians
Navigation
  • Home
  • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
  • Clinical
    • Airway Managment
    • Case Reports
    • Critical Care
    • Guidelines
    • Imaging & Ultrasound
    • Pain & Palliative Care
    • Pediatrics
    • Resuscitation
    • Trauma & Injury
  • Resource Centers
    • mTBI Resource Center
  • Career
    • Practice Management
      • Benchmarking
      • Reimbursement & Coding
      • Care Team
      • Legal
      • Operations
      • Quality & Safety
    • Awards
    • Certification
    • Compensation
    • Early Career
    • Education
    • Leadership
    • Profiles
    • Retirement
    • Work-Life Balance
  • Columns
    • ACEP4U
    • Airway
    • Benchmarking
    • Brief19
    • By the Numbers
    • Coding Wizard
    • EM Cases
    • End of the Rainbow
    • Equity Equation
    • FACEPs in the Crowd
    • Forensic Facts
    • From the College
    • Images in EM
    • Kids Korner
    • Medicolegal Mind
    • Opinion
      • Break Room
      • New Spin
      • Pro-Con
    • Pearls From EM Literature
    • Policy Rx
    • Practice Changers
    • Problem Solvers
    • Residency Spotlight
    • Resident Voice
    • Skeptics’ Guide to Emergency Medicine
    • Sound Advice
    • Special OPs
    • Toxicology Q&A
    • WorldTravelERs
  • Resources
    • ACEP.org
    • ACEP Knowledge Quiz
    • Issue Archives
    • CME Now
    • Annual Scientific Assembly
      • ACEP14
      • ACEP15
      • ACEP16
      • ACEP17
      • ACEP18
      • ACEP19
    • Annals of Emergency Medicine
    • JACEP Open
    • Emergency Medicine Foundation
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • Medical Editor in Chief
    • Editorial Advisory Board
    • Awards
    • Authors
    • Article Submission
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Subscribe
    • Privacy Policy
    • Copyright Information

Can We Trust Health Plan Data? Health Plans Contribute Data to Health Care Cost Institute All-Payer Claims Database

By Myles Riner, MD, FACEP | on August 21, 2014 | 0 Comment
Uncategorized
  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
Print-Friendly Version

Recently three national health plans, Aetna, United Healthcare, and Humana, announced they would contribute claims data to the Health Care Cost Institute (HCCI), a not for profit enterprise supported by Aetna, Humana, Kaiser Permanente, and United Healthcare to promote what they claim will be “independent, nonpartisan research and analysis on the causes of the rise in U.S. health spending.” So HCCI is going to build a database of health care payments based on claims data submitted by health plans. That reminds me of something…oh, yes, INGENIX, the infamous United Health Plan owned database of usual and customary charges that, according to the New York Attorney General, was manipulated by health plans through selective contribution of claims data in order to bilk plan enrollees of hundreds of millions of dollars in benefits. One wonders why health plans might want to send claims data to a plan-supported non-profit enterprise that is collecting PAYMENTS information. Could it be that by selectively submitting claims with lower payments (i.e. deeply discounted contracted payments), the plans could leverage this data in negotiations with providers for deeper discounts, or change legislature and regulator perceptions of the reasonable value of provider services?

You Might Also Like
  • ACEP Says FAIR Health Database Is Fair
  • Vermont to Launch All-Payer Accountable Care Organization Model for Financing Health Care
  • Members Get Discount on Fee Data

According to an article in Law360, David Newman, HCCI’s executive director said that this “database will focus on services that are “truly shoppable,” such as nonemergency surgeries. Policyholders will be able to get detailed information based on their benefits, and even noncustomers will be able to peruse higher-level data that should allow them to find good values on health care services”. He also said: “I think this is going to put pressure on providers.” Christine Chun, the author of the Law360 article, noted that: “the insurers on Wednesday all declined to say whether they expect providers to give ground on prices as a result of the transparency, and they also ducked a question about whether the endeavor might lead more consumers to start viewing provider costs as a key driver of increases in insurance premiums.”

It is pretty clear that the objective of the plans in contributing to this database is not simply to provide transparency in terms of payments made to out-of-network providers and discounts accepted by contracted providers in order to help enrollees shop for less expensive health care services; but to use the database to leverage providers into accepting even lower payments, and to undermine the commercial value of provider services. The thing about a database of contractually discounted payments is that these payments do not reflect any of the value of the considerations that providers obtain from the plans in exchange for the discount (such as an exclusive or preferential referral base or quicker payments). Thus, such a database is likely to significantly under-represent the value of these services in the market. Regulators and legislators who might turn to this database as a surrogate for the reasonable market value of physician or hospital services will come away with inaccurate information, especially if the claims submitted to this database are selectively contributed to over-represent the most heavily discounted or underpaid claims. Only by thoroughly and aggressively auditing and validating such claims submissions by the plans can HCCI ensure that the data is properly representative. Prior experience with Ingenix, and the direct financial relationship between HCCI and the plans, leads me to believe this is not a good bet.

Pages: 1 2 | Single Page

Topics: AetnaClaims DataFAIR HealthHCCIHealth Care Cost InstituteHealth Care PaymentsHeath CostsHumanaKaiser PermanenteUnited Healthcare

Current Issue

ACEP Now May 03

Read More

No Responses to “Can We Trust Health Plan Data? Health Plans Contribute Data to Health Care Cost Institute All-Payer Claims Database”

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*
*


Current Issue

ACEP Now May 03

Read More

Wiley
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2025 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved, including rights for text and data mining and training of artificial technologies or similar technologies. ISSN 2333-2603