Logo

Log In Sign Up |  An official publication of: American College of Emergency Physicians
Navigation
  • Home
  • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
  • Clinical
    • Airway Managment
    • Case Reports
    • Critical Care
    • Guidelines
    • Imaging & Ultrasound
    • Pain & Palliative Care
    • Pediatrics
    • Resuscitation
    • Trauma & Injury
  • Resource Centers
    • mTBI Resource Center
  • Career
    • Practice Management
      • Benchmarking
      • Reimbursement & Coding
      • Care Team
      • Legal
      • Operations
      • Quality & Safety
    • Awards
    • Certification
    • Compensation
    • Early Career
    • Education
    • Leadership
    • Profiles
    • Retirement
    • Work-Life Balance
  • Columns
    • ACEP4U
    • Airway
    • Benchmarking
    • Brief19
    • By the Numbers
    • Coding Wizard
    • EM Cases
    • End of the Rainbow
    • Equity Equation
    • FACEPs in the Crowd
    • Forensic Facts
    • From the College
    • Images in EM
    • Kids Korner
    • Medicolegal Mind
    • Opinion
      • Break Room
      • New Spin
      • Pro-Con
    • Pearls From EM Literature
    • Policy Rx
    • Practice Changers
    • Problem Solvers
    • Residency Spotlight
    • Resident Voice
    • Skeptics’ Guide to Emergency Medicine
    • Sound Advice
    • Special OPs
    • Toxicology Q&A
    • WorldTravelERs
  • Resources
    • ACEP.org
    • ACEP Knowledge Quiz
    • Issue Archives
    • CME Now
    • Annual Scientific Assembly
      • ACEP14
      • ACEP15
      • ACEP16
      • ACEP17
      • ACEP18
      • ACEP19
    • Annals of Emergency Medicine
    • JACEP Open
    • Emergency Medicine Foundation
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • Medical Editor in Chief
    • Editorial Advisory Board
    • Awards
    • Authors
    • Article Submission
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Subscribe
    • Privacy Policy
    • Copyright Information

Avoiding Overdiagnosis and Overtreatment of Urinary Tract Infection in the Emergency Department

By Anton Helman, MD, CCFP(EM), FCFP | on January 16, 2018 | 0 Comment
EM Cases
  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
Print-Friendly Version

Each year, there are more than 1 million ED visits for urinary tract infection (UTI) in the United States.1 Antibiotic treatment for UTIs is avoidable in a significant proportion of patients. Emergency physicians tend to overdiagnose and overtreat because asymptomatic bacteriuria is very common in all age groups, urine cultures are frequently ordered without an appropriate indication, and urinalysis results are often misinterpreted. In this column, my aim is for you to reflect on your practice when it comes to UTI diagnosis and treatment.

You Might Also Like
  • U.S. Hospital Program Reduces Catheter-Associated Urinary Infections
  • Quick-Wee an Easier Way to Get Infant’s Clean Catch Urine Sample
  • Early Fecal Transplant Improves Survival after Severe C. Diff Infection
Explore This Issue
ACEP Now: Vol 37 – No 01 – January 2018

Which Historical Features Are Useful?

No single clinical symptom, sign, or lab test is accurate enough to rule in or out a UTI.2 Only about half of patients who present with dysuria and frequency will have a UTI. However, for those patients who present with dysuria and frequency and do not have any symptoms suggesting vaginitis or cervicitis (vaginal irritation, bleeding, and discharge), the likelihood of a UTI increases to more than 90 percent, with a positive likelihood ratio (+LR) of 24.6.2 Other helpful historical features include a self-diagnosed UTI, which has a +LR of 4 (as good as a positive dipstick), and cloudy urine appearance in a noncatheterized patient, which has a specificity of 96 percent for UTI.2

Which Patients Require a Workup?

Urine tests are not required for the majority of patients with suspected lower UTI, as it is a clinical diagnosis and the urine tests can be misleading, resulting in over- and undertreatment. Urine tests are usually not necessary for very-low-risk patients or for patients with a very convincing clinical presentation, as your posttest probability will not be changed significantly.

Indications for urine tests for suspected lower UTI include those patients with an intermediate pretest probability for UTI, immunocompromised patients, a history of multiple courses of antimicrobial therapy, a history of antibiotic resistance, or a history of multiple drug allergies. Remember that even a urine culture has a 5 percent false-positive rate due, in large part, to asymptomatic bacteriuria and a 25 percent false-negative rate due to antibiotic use and sample overdilution.2

Think About Differential Diagnosis of Pyuria

Not all pyuria is caused by UTI. Pyuria can result from a wide array of conditions. Dehydration, acute renal failure, sexually transmitted infections, appendicitis, diverticulitis, and the presence of a bladder catheter can all cause white blood cell counts of more than 5 cells/mL on microscopy. While pyuria on its own has a sensitivity as high as 94 percent, its specificity is poor unless combined with positive nitrite. Pyuria and positive nitrite in the setting of a clinical history for UTI has a specificity of 100 percent. However, if microscopy in isolation is used, the result is overtreating 44 percent and undertreating 11 percent of UTIs.4 The urine dipstick is even worse. If the dipstick is used in isolation, UTIs are overtreated 47 percent and undertreated 13 percent.

Interpreting Epithelial Cells and Bacteria on Urine Microscopy

The classic teaching is that more than five epithelial cells per high-powered field represents an uncontaminated sample.4 However, while a “contaminated” sample may negatively affect the ability to obtain a reliable culture, it does not affect the accuracy of the dipstick or microscopy to the same degree. While bacteria seen on microscopy is predictive of a positive culture, it is not necessarily diagnostic of a UTI, as the positive culture could represent a contaminant or asymptomatic bacteriuria. Just as bladder catheters can cause pyuria, they can cause bacteriuria without UTI as well.5

Which Patients Require Antibiotics for Asymptomatic Bacteriuria?

According to the Infectious Diseases Society of America, asymptomatic bacteriuria is not linked to long-term adverse outcomes, and treatment does not decrease the rate of symptomatic UTI.6 Asymptomatic bacteriuria is very common in all age groups and is often misdiagnosed as a UTI. Antibiotics for asymptomatic bacteriuria should only be considered in patients undergoing an invasive urologic procedure and in pregnant patients.

Pages: 1 2 3 | Single Page

Topics: AntibioticsEmergency DepartmentEmergency MedicineEmergency PhysiciansOverdiagnosisOvertreatmentPatient CareUrinary Tract InfectionUTI

Related

  • EM Runs in the Family

    February 26, 2025 - 0 Comment
  • Settling the Cefepime versus Piperacillin-Tazobactam Debate

    November 7, 2024 - 0 Comment
  • Diagnosing Lower Urinary Tract Infections

    May 10, 2024 - 0 Comment

Current Issue

ACEP Now May 03

Read More

About the Author

Anton Helman, MD, CCFP(EM), FCFP

Dr. Helman is an emergency physician at North York General Hospital in Toronto. He is an assistant professor at the University of Toronto, Division of Emergency Medicine, and the education innovation lead at the Schwartz/Reisman Emergency Medicine Institute. He is the founder and host of Emergency Medicine Cases podcast and website (www.emergencymedicinecases.com).

View this author's posts »

No Responses to “Avoiding Overdiagnosis and Overtreatment of Urinary Tract Infection in the Emergency Department”

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*
*

Wiley
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2025 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved, including rights for text and data mining and training of artificial technologies or similar technologies. ISSN 2333-2603